Children of the Kernel
“Tell me something about your child?” … OK, just give me a few seconds to ask my virtual assistant for some ideas. That may sound like a crazy exchange, but it’s a version of the future being sold by AI’s true believers. I love a lot about tech, but I wonder if we wouldn’t have been better off stopping our progress right around the time we got streaming movies to stop buffering. Marissa Mayer’s new company, Dazzle, uses AI to analyze your camera roll to become a sort of visuals-powered assistant. Potential customers can decide whether they see value in that offering, but what is most perplexing about the product launch is the first example of a use case. “Late last year, Marissa Mayer was struggling with what felt like an impossible task. Her daughter Marielle was turning 10, and Marielle’s teacher wanted three bullet points summarizing what made her special. Mayer — the former chief executive of Yahoo and a pioneer at Google, where she was the first female engineer — likes cracking a hard problem. But she felt overwhelmed by the range and complexity of potential answers. So Mayer asked her personal A.I. assistant, Dazzle. Within a few seconds, Dazzle delivered an answer.” NYT (Gift Article): Marissa Mayer Ran Yahoo. She’s Back With A.I. She Thinks Women Will Love. Women may love this product. But I’ll be shocked if they love this use case. I can see pitching a product that saves time on your busywork so you can spend more of it with your children. But a product that saves you the time you’d spend thinking of ways to describe your children by letting the machine describe them instead? This is an example of what I think is a broad and growing disconnect between what people want and what AI CEOs think people want. Necessity is the mother of invention. But that’s being reversed. Invention has become the mother of necessity. But do we really need to replace our humanity? We’ve seen generations of children grow up and eventually complain to their therapists about their parents. Will this generation of kids end up complaining to their therapists about the AI brand their parents chose to deploy? “ChatGPT never really loved me!” “Muse was always late for my violin recitals!” “Dazzle made me self-conscious about my appearance!” “I always felt like I needed more from Claude, but I ran out of tokens.” Actually, who am I kidding? By then, their therapists will be AI, too.
+ NYT (Gift Article): Why Some People Are Paying to Make Friends. “Fueled by a loneliness epidemic and increasingly online lifestyles, more people are paying start-ups to make new friends offline. And friend-matching companies such as Real Roots, 222 and Timeleft are exploding in popularity as a result, each one generating millions of dollars in revenue annually.” This is one of the more common trends of the digital age: Technology creates a problem, and the solution that gets offered is more technology. I’ve been writing about this issue for years. The idea that we need a technological solution for too much technology is the Internet era’s great placebo effect. We feel like we’re getting a little better, but it’s just part of the same addiction. Because it’s their business, tech companies really have no choice but to try to convince us that we’re just one more piece of technology away from the solution, but it’s like telling us we can use heroin to kick our methadone habit—when we all know deep down that the off switch is the only true killer app. I hope that view makes my AI mother proud.


